Tuesday, December 13, 2016

Final Blossay: Miyazaki Protagonists

Miyazaki is well known for his female protagonists’ strength. In my blossay I will be exploring three of these protagonists. The films I will be looking at consist of Spirited Away, Princess Mononoke, and Nausicaa. These films are all extremely powerful and their protagonists face great difficulties in their stories. Miyazaki's female characters make themselves remembered through their strengths. They are representations of who many of us aspire to be. "Many of Miyazaki's female characters are remarkable for taking charge of their lives" (1).
Image result for miyazaki
To begin with, Spirited Away focuses on a ten year old girl named Chihiro. Chihiro and her parents enter into a strange place that seems like an abandoned carnival and her parents end up finding a food station with a ton of food. Chihiro who has been freaked out since they left their car, refuses to join her parents who are eating at the abandoned buffet. Chihiro is actually the most unique protagonist of the three I am going to focus on. This is due to the fact that where almost all of Miyazaki's protagonists come across great problems, they tend to only be triggered by anger to act out. Chihiro is afraid of everything when she arrives in the spirit world. She is constantly panicking at each new aspect of the world that she is exposed to. She is not brave or powerful or even competent. She actually matches, in many ways, her antagonist's description of her: that she is pathetic and stupid. Chihiro gains strength throughout the film, learning to stand on her own two feet rather than rely on her new friend Haku who saved her life. Still, she is seen as a crybaby who has never worked in her life. What she does have from the beginning is the stubbornness that goes along with Miyazaki heroines. She demonstrates this when she first comes into contact with Yubaba, our main antagonist in the film. When Chihiro comes to seek a job with her in order to be able to remain in the spirit world unharmed, Yubaba tries to talk the girl out of it and deny her the position. Chihiro, despite her fear of Yubaba, holds her ground and continues asking for work. She does this in spite of having her mouth zipped shut, something that must have been shocking, and Yubaba's threats. When Yubaba finally allows Chihiro to sign a work contract, Yubaba takes away Chihiro's name, making her Sen.  Chihiro does not panic about her loss of name. She seems to take this one fact in stride. Her character is highly loyal to those she considers her friends or family. This is perhaps most evident in the way she deals with Haku, although it first becomes known when she goes to talk to her parents and yells that she won't let them be eaten and that she would save them. Chihiro is the character that grows the most in her story. She works hard, if cluelessly at the bathhouse. Her transformation from a crybaby to a brave child is a slow and steady process where as my other protagonists are really much more straightforward.  Susan Napier says that "the whiny and sullen Chihiro also stands in strong contrast to virtually every other Miyazaki child protagonist" (3),Image result for chihiro crying but I strongly disagree with this overly simplistic view of Chihiro. It only focuses on one aspect of Chihiro and ignores others that show her to be as brave and committed as any of Miyazaki's character. The quote is a bit of a dig at Chihiro's character, saying that she is only a "whiny and sullen child" but I think it is the transformation and perseverance through her fears and doubts that make Chihiro worthy of being a Miyazaki character. She faces two major challenges: dealing with Noh Face and saving Haku. In working to save Haku after she sees that he is being attacked by thousands of small paper cutouts, she is determined to save Haku no matter what adversaries she must face. Her first act is to save him from being pushed to his death by the three heads. She stands against the three heads and the tyrannical baby of Yubaba's who wants to be played with. She wrestles with Haku in his dragon form to get him to eat the medicine that she got from the river god that she helped by noticing that there was a "thorn" stuck in his side that turns out to be a bicycle.Image result for chihiro and haku dragon What I find most interesting about her bravery is that she is not fearless in her bravery, merely determined to do what she needs to. She feeds the rest of the medicine to Noh Face to get him to be healthy again and lets him accompany her. Her version of bravery is so much stronger than it would be in an inherently brave character because she overcomes her fear and conquers it. She learns how to deal with everything.
Image result for princess mononoke
Princess Mononoke on the other hand is brave and fearless throughout the film. She is powerful and harnesses her instincts gained from living with the wolves to be a fearsome warrior. Princess Mononoke is a teenager or very young adult and the challenges she faces are harder and in a wider context than her life and a few others. She is embroiled in a war between man and nature, both internally and externally. She lacks the diplomacy and understanding of Nausicaa and Chihiro respectively. She is dedicated to the protection of the forest and the deer god and is not afraid of death for herself. She is impulsive and aggressive as seen by her battle with Lady Eboshi. When the two fight at the iron works,Image result for princess mononoke lady eboshi the two seem evenly matched although Princess Mononoke has already fought several guards and been shot off the roof. Ashitaka, the main male character that connects Princess Mononoke's and Lady Eboshi's world, steps between the two women to stop the fight causing rage from the Lady Eboshi's people as he knocks both women unconscious. Despite Princess Mononoke's hatred of human beings because of what they did to the forest, when Ashitaka is shot, she takes him to be healed by the deer god. Mononoke's hatred of human beings is one of her driving forces, along with her family, the wolves. She is okay with killing if she needs to, although she did not try to kill anyone besides Lady Eboshi who is the main source of danger. She is willing to fight to save her home and even follow the boars to their deaths in order to help her friend, the leader of the boars. One thing that really strikes me about Mononoke is that she does not really change in any discernible way in the film. She remains strong and loyal to the forest and continues to hate humans. She would have let her rage lead her to murder the injured Lady Eboshi. Her personality is unaltering.  She does not learn to compromise with anyone or communicate. The closest she comes is with Ashitaka, who she has fallen in love with, when she wants to kill Lady Eboshi, and that is less of a discussion than Ahitaka's unfaltering demand.
Nausicaa is the character that is most involved in the lives of those around her. As a princess, Nausicaa is very much in the public eye of her people unlike Princess Mononoke. Both are around the same age as each other and there is a lot of overlap in traits between Mononoke and Nausicaa. Nausicaa feels the same initial need to seek revenge that we see so strongly in Mononoke, but Nausicaa is overcome by disgust and fear from her aggressive response. She has no desire to cause harm, but rather a desire for peace. She stops her people from rioting against the invading forces in order to preserve their lives. She also gives herself up as a prisoner to keep the peace. This is where the two young women differ. Nausicaa will sacrifice herself like princess Mononoke in a heartbeat, but not through violence. She will risk her life for peace rather than victory. Lucy Wright says this about Nausicaa: "Her characterization can be read as signifying transitional and purifying aspects, and the unusual power she possesses as affirmative of the "rightness" of her mode of thought" (2). She is in many ways a reflection of what the Sea of Decay hides: the key to healing the world. Image result for nausicaa and ohmuHer ideals are powerful and beautiful and do not have high costs like the plans of Kushana's people and the people of Pejite. She is dedicated to her people, but she is shown to have respect for all living things. Notable, she has formed a connection with many of the creatures in the Sea of Decay that threatens them all. She instead looks for an answer as to what the danger actually is and how to mitigate the dangers that are killing humans who fail to use proper protection such as what are essentially gas masks. She is also forgiving. She seeks no retribution against Kushana and her people who are oppressing Nausicaa's people and the survivors of Pejite who both use the Valley of the wind where Nausicaa and her people live as a battle ground for their battles. She is the most intelligent of the three protagonists, taking a scientific look at the Sea of Decay. Image result for nausicaaHer greatest strength though is her ability to compromise while also holding to her morals without compromise. She is as kind as Chihiro and as strong as Princess Mononoke. She is kindness in the face of destruction and power in the face of peace. Her understanding of the ohmu protects her people and the people in the other factions. She represents internal power where the other factions use outside forces to effect the world around them and gain power. She, like Princess Mononoke enters the final battle. Her goal is to stop the battle where Princess Mononoke meant to support the clash between man and nature in favor of nature. She does manage to stop it through her sacrifice and her returning of the young ohmu.
Why are these three characters so important? Each has bravery expressed in their own way and they are all stubbornly committed to their causes. Miyazaki "encouraged the assimilation and appreciation of foreign cultural elements" (2) which can be seen in the way these characters appeal to both cultures more heavily than any other anime. The characters are both distinctly Japanese in terms of culture and the world, but Miyazaki also promotes characteristics that heavily appeal to a western civilization. It intrigued me that Chihiro at ten is so different from the slightly older characters of Nausicaa and Princess Mononoke. Is it a question of age or is another personality being expressed? Based on Chihiro's evolution compared to the relatively static older characters, I would say that it is based on age. At ten years old, the world is so new still and new things are always being discovered which may be why Chihiro is able to change so much. She is far more adaptable, personality wise, than the other characters. She mentally "grows up" in the course of the story, picking herself up when she falls and becoming independent and strong. Our other two characters are more stable in their personality. To compare it to a novel, in golden compass, everyone has a daemon. When they are children, the daemons have not settled on a form, changing between multiple animals. At about thirteen (puberty), the daemons settle into a form. Chihiro's experiences are still forming her base personality, allowing for more extensive growth. Princess Mononoke and Nausicaa both live in harsher worlds where death is a regular part of life unlike Chihiro's modern day lifestyle. They developed most likely throughout their lives to understand the world they were in and its demands and by young adulthood, they had chosen their paths. They contain a strength of character that Chihiro is only beginning to comprehend and they wield it as their weapons. Nausicaa's strength allowed her to save the baby ohmu that had been kidnapped by the Pejite faction despite her normally pacifistic approach. She did not give up when the ohmu turned towards her people, but made a plan to stop the attack. She wanted to return the baby for the baby's sake as much as for her people's sake. Mononoke was the unbreakable wall that met the unstoppable force of Lady Eboshi and human progress. She did not break in the end, going back to live in the regrowing forest, but nor was she able to prevent the very event that she had been attempting to stop. She takes her defeat and picks herself up to continue to protect the forest.
These characters all share characteristics, but the strongest for me is neither the physically or mentally strongest: It is Chihiro for her ability to change and learn and take away her lessons to become stronger. With that attitude, she can continue to grow stronger while Mononoke and Nausicaa have deceived their own strength. Each character is fully developed in Miyazaki's films, but showing the character in its entirety and letting a character grow are different issues. What Miyazaki gives us in these three films are three examples of what strength and bravery are. There are different types and none are inherently better than another. What is crucial is that each of these female characters, despite their overlaps, are their own character. I wanted to find out if Miyazaki reused his protagonists and just changed the setting like many writers do or if they were their own characters- individuals. Miyazaki's protagonists are undoubtedly individuals both in creation and in the fact that they can operate autonomously and accomplish great things.
I apologize for not including our favorite antagonists. It just didn't fit in the scope of the paper!




(1)   "Confronting Master Narratives: History As Vision in Miyazaki Hayao's Cinema of De-assurance" by Susan Napier. http://muse.jhu.edu/article/27987
(3)   "Matter Out of Place: Carnival, Containment, and Cultural Recovery in Miyazaki's Spirited Away" By Susan Napier. http://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/25064646.pdf

Basic details: 
(4)   https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nausicaä_of_the_Valley_of_the_Wind_(film)

(5)   https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Princess_Mononoke

Pictures:
https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhx7sbOQOdgwS4GcFDHYMz3AQywvzWdiX3-m6xLG2UytInsFsZt8ABpt-jC6aFRSLYN6YhtQtqhc4ckq_ML_O61-YBZm4i5aUTuQ8DgOMdbp0HUCJbCcVmkbgyY-txlEM99-P-BZUJh0Rh4/s1600/ChihiroDragonhaku.png
https://visocki.files.wordpress.com/2012/02/sa_cry.jpg
https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/564x/c6/9c/be/c69cbe503b8277bad5adc9f13c8f749b.jpg
http://entropymag.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/the-great-japanese-epic-from-studio-ghibli-princess-mononoke-1997-princess-mononoke.jpeg
http://anime.astronerdboy.com/wp-content/uploads/blogger/-DGMRP8uG4VI/Tdx-ffv4udI/AAAAAAAAWhE/6NLH__xqqKg/s1600/13%2Bsaving%2Bthe%2Bbaby%2BOhmu.jpg
https://partofyourworldksu.files.wordpress.com/2015/03/nausicaa-nausicaa-of-the-valley-of-the-wind-33424551-3390-1920.jpg
http://www.indiewire.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/the-films-of-hayao-miyazaki.jpg

No comments:

Post a Comment